Monday, November 16, 2026

EXCELLENT ―We Must End Neoliberalism, or Neoliberalism Will End Us―and Other Empowering Resources

This is a deeply important, well articulated, and illuminating article from 2019 that I am moved to repost today. In addition, included here are also other excellent resources. I believe that it is of critical importance that we spread the truth in an ongoing way about neoliberalism and its devastating impacts on our political system and the mainstream corporate media, our country and other nations, all life on Earth and our shared beautiful hurting planet. It is vital that we are an informed populace empowered to act in our own best interests and that of all life everywhere.  And we can only do so as we are able to recognize and shed the layers that we have absorbed in our culture of the imperialist, white-supremacist, neoliberal capitalist, misogynistic patriarchy that we have been born into. If you haven't already, please take this deep dive into the truth about neoliberalism. Thank you. Another world is possible! — Molly

Protesters attend a demonstration for climate protection in Dortmund, Germany, on August 2, 2019.INA FASSBENDER / AFP / GETTY IMAGES
 We must choose the well-being of our communities over neoliberalism’s false promise of individual freedoms.
 

In his seminal political essay, “The Power of the Powerless,” the dissident playwright and philosopher Vaclav Havel argued that becoming empowered requires us to “live in truth,” which means facing up to the uncomfortable reality that we are not solely victims of the political and economic order we live under, but sometimes also enablers who play into its myths and cover up its lies. We turn the lies into truth and come to believe it is the only way to get through, the only way to survive in what we are told again and again is a “dog-eat-dog” world.

It is this uncomfortable truth that inevitably raises the question: Why has neoliberalism succeeded so well? The answer is unsettling precisely because it implicates all of us — at least all of us who live in industrial capitalist countries. Even if we are not equally blameworthy in creating such a monstrous ideology, we have all, in some measure, been co-opted into accepting neoliberal capitalism’s false premises and promises.

It is quite true that domestic and international economic and political structures that legitimize neoliberal capitalism are oriented by, and in the interest of, an elite corporate class. Yet in the wake of the 2007-2008 financial crisis — the worst economic crash since 1929 — there has been no massive global uprising or any sustained call for radical institutional reform (with the exception of the short-lived grassroots Occupy Wall Street movement, and to some extent, France’s Yellow Vests movement).

Continuous rebellion and dissent leading to revolution has not happened because we appear to have tacitly bought into an ideology that ensures our own powerlessness to transform ourselves or our societies. The good news is that this is changing. In the last few years, many have become conscious of the fact that civilizational collapse as a consequence of human-caused climate disruption is directly attributable to an economic and political system that views the Earth and everything that lives on it as an inexhaustible means for individual and corporate profit.

For the first time in human history, we are confronted by the near certainty of global ecological catastrophe and its resulting political and economic breakdown — not as a consequence of natural causes, nor the vengeful act of a deity, but as a result of deliberate human choice. The brutal reality is that the present world of neoliberal economics and politics simply could not have survived had we not gradually acquiesced to it. So how did this happen?

The Beginnings of Neoliberal Thought    

Let’s begin with the following truism: When compared to more brutalizing regimes of dominance and militaristic authoritarianism throughout history, we do have a greater measure of freedom today. With the emergence of liberal social rights and the United Nations recognition and validation of international human rights after the horrors of two world wars, the corporate power elite and the governments that do their bidding implicitly understood that there would no longer be any toleration for political ideologies whose goal was to brutally repress human beings. So, the question for the latter was always how to ensure that the right class continued to be in a position of control and dominance, while at least providing the appearance of freedom and democracy for everyone else.

First, what is required is the semblance of choice and economic power — an ersatz form of freedom realized through the mythical “self-organizing” and “self-correcting” “free market.” Free-market laissez-faire monopoly capitalism is expressly designed to counter any attempts by government to impose regulations on behalf of the public good that might impede profit, and to redefine citizens wholly as consumers. Human well-being is thereby reduced to a purely economic index.  

Secondly, what is required is the semblance of democracy by way of electoral representative politics organized and paid for by moneyed interests. Lastly, what is required is the semblance of liberal institutional arrangements (education, social security, health care, policing, environmental and labor regulatory bodies) that increasingly do not serve public interest, but protect and serve private profit and business interests.

In conjunction with ersatz freedom of choice, democracy and the semblance of public institutions which appear to further or protect the public good, there is also what Havel might have called the semblance of liberal dissidence — those persons, regulatory bodies and political parties who make a pretense of fighting on behalf of the public good and in favor of health, labor and environmental rights, while continuing to forward a corporate rights agenda behind the backs of citizens.

In the contemporary world, the corporate capitalist class and the neoliberal governments that do their bidding have been able to maintain the upper hand not through sheer force or brutality, but because they have gradually been allowed to corrode democratic institutions and eviscerate the commons and, therefore, any sense of mutual obligation and responsibility humans have toward each other.

Neoliberalism and Instrumental Reasoning

It is crucial to recognize here that modern capitalism from the 19th century emerged in tandem with a particular sort of instrumental reasoning — the sort of use-oriented reasoning that seems innocuous and practical because it enables us to “get things done.”    

When we want to realize a particular end — say, build a house or mend a fence, we reason in an instrumental fashion — that is, we calculate what we need to do in order to successfully realize an end or achieve a goal. Instrumental reasoning does not tell us why we value ideas such as justice, love, courage, or why we care about other human beings, other animals or the planet. It is not about understanding or valuing the world, but always about how to succeed at realizing a goal in the most orderly and efficient way.

Modern bureaucracies and the administrative state are founded on instrumental rationality. However, when divorced from deeper human concerns about social and environmental justice, instrumental reasoning can become dehumanizing, hegemonic and, indeed, life-annihilating.

Imperialist bureaucracies and Nazi death camps were grounded in a form of instrumental reasoning detached from any sort of deeper value-oriented rationality that might speak to notions of human rights or dignity. The goal of genocide was enacted through Nazi bureaucracy and enabled by instrumental reasoning that was orderly, precise, lawful and lethal.

In the context of contemporary neoliberal capitalism, instrumental reasoning plays a pivotal enabling and legitimating role. If my end or goal is wealth or profit, then any means that will help me efficiently achieve this end is “rationally” acceptable, and even laudable.

When this sort of instrumental reasoning is married to a capitalist theory of human nature that views human beings as egotistic, competitive self-maximizers, and a neoliberal theory of economics and politics based on imperialism, technical control and domination of the planet, it must inevitably displace any sort of deeper value questions about the quality of life, the well-being of human communities and health of the biosphere.

From an instrumental reasoning perspective, we as a society have bought into the seductive discourses and practices of neoliberal capitalism by embracing the myths of individual consumer freedom and self-empowering entrepreneurship. The exercise of virtues that enable us to flourish as communities and nations are all jettisoned when instrumental reasoning and neoliberal capitalism become hegemonic.

Even when we appear at times to resist the logic of unjust outcomes that goes with neoliberalism, or question its theoretical or moral legitimacy, the fact remains that our politics, mainstream newspapers and electronic media, schools of economics and institutional arrangements, have been infiltrated, disciplined and systemically reframed by neoliberal doctrine, and legitimated through utilitarian calculation and instrumental reasoning.

Indeed, even the false mantra that “there is no viable alternative to capitalism” pervades modern thinking to such a degree that a wholly different kind of economics and politics has often seemed unthinkable to many. There is no need for brute force nor even overt forms of propaganda in such a world because the central presuppositions of neoliberalism have been normalized and mainstreamed in everyday society. 

Moreover, transnational corporate class interests are protected by private security and public police forces; they are fortified and universalized by international bodies, such as the International Monetary Fund and World Bank, corporate lobby groups, Chambers of Commerce, Business Councils and roundtables, neoconservative think tanks, corporate super PACs and nonprofit corporate front groups such as the American Legislative Exchange Council that draft legislation in the interests of corporations, and against environmental regulations, corporate taxation and labor rights.

Given all of the above, any talk of revolution or even the notion of mass citizen uprising resistance or rebellion might seem to be nothing less than delusional.

That is, until now.

Neoliberalism Versus the Climate

If there is one thing that history has made clear to us again and again, it is that no human construction is eternal, all-pervasive or invulnerable to change. Reality has a way of disrupting the status quo, messing up well-laid plans and invalidating conventional pieties.     

In the last 20 years, reality has asserted itself in a way unprecedented in human history. For the first time, we are imminently threatened as a species because we have chosen an economic and political system that treats the planet as if it were no more than a means for infinite exploitation and individual wealth, rather than a limited Earth that only conditionally provides the possibility for all forms of life.

In an unprecedented way, what has come into focus today is both the limiting nature of instrumental reasoning and the life-destroying impact of neoliberal capitalism to which it is wedded. Climate disruption as a consequence of human-caused planetary warming has brought into sharp focus two stark and undeniable truths        

  1. For the first time in human history, we have put more than a million different species at risk of extinction including our own.
  2. The economic system of capitalism and its most recent neoliberal configuration is the principal cause of the present climate crisis that threatens human and other species’ survival.

The growing recognition of the above truths has pressed us to finally ask deeper questions about what we really value: the quality of life, the well-being of human and other forms of life, the health of our communities and food systems, and the safety and dignity of persons in the context of massive climate disruption.

For the first time, we are asking how is it that we have come to accept the kind of instrumental rationality and neoliberal economic and political system that not only dehumanizes us as individuals but will inevitably destroy life as we know it. Those who financially benefit from the system of neoliberal capitalism would have us believe that we cannot change or transform the world into a better, more equal, more caring, environmentally sustainable and responsible place. But the fact is there are individuals and groups emerging and multiplying around the world whose actions demonstrate the neoliberal capitalist worldview is no longer viable. They are doing unprecedented things: putting forth Green New Deals that forward new ways of thinking and doing economics and politics; investing in and building environmentally sustainable alternative energy systems and modes of transportation and agriculture; demanding food sovereignty; and promoting local forms of banking, governance and sustainable living.

What has become apparent to the rapidly growing numbers who are building alternative ways of living is that capitalism must end. Historically, critiques of capitalism focused on worker alienation and exploitation, imperialism, profound disparities of wealth, market instability and the erosion of democracy. However, all of the latter pale in comparison to the critique of capital based on the very foreseeable potential it has to completely destroy the very conditions of possibility for life itself.

For the first time in the history of humankind, we are forced to admit that gradualism, half-measures and tinkering will no longer suffice. We either completely break with capitalism and the neoliberal ideology that enables it, or we face extinction. Economic and political systems that destroy the Earth, gradually erode human freedom and undermine social, environmental and economic justice only appeared unstoppable because we once saw them as inevitable, necessary or absolute. With the rise of climate change consciousness, we now see them for what they have always been: contingent human choices and deliberate human constructions that we must not accede to any longer. That will require a revolution — not just in thinking and lifestyles but fundamentally in our politics and in our economics.

At the end of his essay Havel concludes that the real question is whether a better future is really all that distant: “What if, on the contrary, it has been here for a long time already, and only our own blindness and weakness has prevented us from seeing it around us and within us, and kept us from developing it?”

What if, indeed.    

* * * * *

 Additional Resources

An Excellent Talk Given by George Monbiot:

The Invisible Ideology: 
Consumerism, Capitalism, and Neoliberalsim

The Invisible Ideology - An amazing talk from the well known author and Guardian journalist George Monbiot. George delves deep into the invisible ideologies trashing our planet. In this video George talks in depth about capitalism, consumerism and neo-liberalism. For the live Q & A with the audience click the link below - https://youtu.be/nN16yWvFcQ0

Two More Excellent Videos:

  • This Is Neoliberalism: Introducing the Invisible Ideology (Part I) ―  Neoliberalism is an economic ideology that exists within the framework of capitalism. Over four decades ago, neoliberalism become the dominant economic paradigm of global society. In this video series, we'll trace the history of neoliberalism, starting with a survey of neoliberal philosophy and research, a historical reconstruction of the movement pushing for neoliberal policy solutions, witnessing the damage that neoliberalism did to its first victims in the developing world, and then charting neoliberalism's infiltration of the political systems of the United States and the United Kingdom. Learn how neoliberalism is generating crises for humanity at an unprecedented rate. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myH3gg5o0t0)
  • This Is Neoliberalism: Keynesian Embedded Liberalism (Part 2) ― Neoliberalism was a reaction. It was an effort to disassemble a previous vision of society that once held sway over most of the world. In order to understand neoliberalism, it’s important to first understand the world before neoliberalism; the world which neoliberalism considered unacceptable, and in need of urgent reconfiguration. Learn about the world of embedded liberalism. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkBpqLWFNg4)

Other Readings:

  • From a book review of A Brief History of Neoliberalism by David Harvey: "It has been part of the genius of neoliberal theory to provide a benevolent mask full of wonderful-sounding words like freedom, liberty, choice, and rights, to hide the grim realities of the restoration or reconstitution of naked class power, locally as well as transnationally, but most particularly in the main financial centres of global capitalism." (https://notes-taken.blogspot.com/2010/07/brief-history-of-neoliberalism-chapter.html)
  • In Paul Verhaeghe's article "Neoliberalism has brought out the worst in us," he writes: A neoliberal meritocracy would have us believe that success depends on individual effort and talents, meaning responsibility lies entirely with the individual and authorities should give people as much freedom as possible to achieve this goal. For those who believe in the fairytale of unrestricted choice, self-government and self-management are the pre-eminent political messages, especially if they appear to promise freedom. Along with the idea of the perfectible individual, the freedom we perceive ourselves as having in the west is the greatest untruth of this day and age." (https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/29/neoliberalism-economic-system-ethics-personality-psychopathicsthic)
  • In "A Short History of Neoliberalism," Susan George writes: "Lest you thought I had forgotten Ronald Reagan, let me illustrate this point with the observations of Kevin Phillips, a Republican analyst and former aid to President Nixon, who published a book in 1990 called The Politics of Rich and Poor. He charted the way Reagan's neo-liberal doctrine and policies had changed American income distribution between 1977 and 1988. These policies were largely elaborated by the conservative Heritage Foundation, the principle think-tank of the Reagan administration and still an important force in American politics. Over the decade of the 1980s, the top 10 percent of American families increased their average family income by 16 percent, the top 5 percent increased theirs by 23 percent, but the extremely lucky top 1 percent of American families could thank Reagan for a 50 percent increase. Their revenues went from an affluent $270.000 to a heady $405.000. As for poorer Americans, the bottom 80 percent all lost something; true to the rule, the lower they were on the scale, the more they lost. The bottom 10 percent of Americans reached the nadir: according to Phillip's figures, they lost 15% of their already meagre incomes: from an already rock-bottom average of $4.113 annually, they dropped to an inhuman $3.504. In 1977, the top 1 percent of American families had average incomes 65 times as great as those of the bottom 10 percent. A decade later, the top 1 percent was 115 times as well off as the bottom decile." (https://www.tni.org/en/article/a-short-history-of-neoliberalism)

10 Reasons Chuck Schumer Should Not Be Senate Majority Leader

An excellent, spot on, and illuminating piece as to why we must oppose Chuck Schumer as strongly as we can. Please call your senators and representatives and ask that they block both Schumer and Jeffries from leadership positions in the Democratic Party. 

And since this article was written, Chris Van Hollen has now openly said that he will be opposing Schumer for Senate Majority Leader. I am so grateful! When calling your senators and representatives, please also ask that they endorse Senator Van Hollen.

We urgently need to dismantle the neoliberal forces within the Democratic Party that have long been supporting a toxic status quo which has for decades caused do much harm. If we don't address the core reasons that brought us Trump twice, we will violate the mandate the midterm elections are demanding. And that would lay the groundwork for yet another fascist takeover of our government. The devastating impacts of entrenched power within both major political parties is what we must work collaboratively together to end. And the only way to do that is to dismantle the neoliberalism which has served to block any true radical progressive change for decades for our nation and the world. This is what must change! — Molly

Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) speaks on the steps of the U.S. Senate during an event with congressional Democrats on May 21, 2026 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Win McNamee/Getty Images)
The voters have spoken. They want more than a change in which party controls Congress—they want a change in direction, a break from politics as usual, and leaders willing to challenge entrenched power.

By 

Democrats have just won back control of Congress, delivering a major rebuke to Donald Trump and his policies. But now comes another critical question: Who should lead the new Democratic majority? Let’s look at the Senate.

Chuck Schumer has been in Congress for nearly 46 years—18 in the House and almost 28 in the Senate. He has led Senate Democrats since 2017 and is already declaring that he expects to be reelected majority leader.

But the public is clamoring for new leadership. A recent NBC News poll found that just 13% of voters view Schumer favorably! While most sitting senators seem reluctant to oppose him, eight newly elected Democratic senators—Abdul El-Sayed, Peggy Flanagan, Troy Jackson, Juliana Stratton, Adam Hamilton, James Talarico, Chris Pappas, and Annie Andrews—have either openly opposed Chuck Schumer or withheld their support. And there is a possibility that Senator Van Hollen will put his hat in the ring.

In addition to 10 reasons that Hakeem Jeffries should not be the next Speaker of the House, here are 10 reasons why Schumer should not lead Democrats in the US Senate.

1. He continues to defend Israel

Few issues demonstrate the growing divide between Democratic leaders and their progressive base more clearly than Israel.

Schumer has described himself as a Shomer Yisrael, a guardian of Israel, pledging to fulfill that role “unflinchingly, unstintingly and with all of my strength.” In a March 2024 Senate speech, delivered as Israel’s assault on Gaza was provoking worldwide outrage, Schumer declared, “We love Israel in our bones,” and described establishment of the state of Israel as one of the most heartfelt causes of his life.

He has condemned the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement and encouraged states to take action against boycotts of Israel.

According to OpenSecrets, Chuck Schumer has received more than $1.7 million in campaign contributions from pro-Israel interests over his congressional career, placing him among the largest recipients of such funding.

In July 2025, as images of starvation and mass civilian suffering in Gaza horrified the world, Bernie Sanders forced Senate votes on resolutions blocking certain weapons sales to Israel. In an extraordinary shift, a majority of Senate Democrats supported restrictions on those transfers. Schumer voted against both resolutions.

Schumer has criticized Netanyahu and Israeli settler violence, yet he continues to support weapons sales to Israel and has not called for ending the nearly $4 billion in annual U.S. military aid—something that, ironically, both Trump and Netanyahu have suggested. Nor has he publicly opposed Section 1217 of the National Defense Authorization Act, which would deepen U.S.-Israeli military integration through joint weapons research, technology development, and defense production.

There’s no way Schumer would lead the Senate in carrying out what the voters want: An end to support for Israel.

2. His career is deeply intertwined with Wall Street, corporate donors, and PACs

Schumer’s relationships with wealthy donors are among the most consequential features of his political career. Representing New York, the center of American finance, he has cultivated close ties with Wall Street executives, major banks, investment firms, and powerful corporate interests. His 2022 reelection campaign raised nearly $38 million, including hundreds of thousands of dollars from PACs and employees associated with financial giants Blackstone, KKR, and BlackRock.

These connections go far beyond campaign contributions. Between 1989 and 2010 alone, Schumer received nearly $9 million from the securities and investment industry. In 2007, he helped obstruct efforts to close the notorious carried-interest loophole, which allows wealthy private-equity managers to pay preferential tax rates on certain earnings. That same year, he championed proposals to ease Wall Street regulations—just before the financial crisis devastated millions of American families.

These corporate donors aren’t giving money out of charity. They have billions at stake in congressional decisions on taxes, healthcare, financial regulation, and military spending. Schumer may talk about standing up for working people, but how can Democrats credibly challenge corporate greed and Wall Street power when their leader has spent decades cultivating the very industries they claim to confront?

3. He has refused to embrace Medicare for All

Millions of Americans struggle with medical debt, insurance denials, enormous deductibles, and the constant fear that illness could destroy their financial security. Schumer identified healthcare affordability as one of five major priorities for the new Democratic Congress. Yet he has refused to embrace the real solution: Medicare for All.

In April 2025, Bernie Sanders introduced legislation to establish such a comprehensive national health program that could save an estimated $1 trillion a year by cutting out private insurance companies while guaranteeing healthcare for everyone. Among its original cosponsors were Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker, Jeff Merkley, and Schumer’s fellow New York senator, Kirsten Gillibrand.

Schumer was conspicuously absent and never brought the bill to a Senate floor vote, even when Democrats controlled the chamber.

Instead, he has focused on expanding the Affordable Care Act, providing subsidies to make private insurance more affordable, and lowering prescription drug costs. But those policies preserve a system in which private insurance companies retain enormous power over patients’ access to healthcare.

It’s no mystery why. Schumer has received millions in campaign contributions from pharmaceutical and insurance industry interests.

The Democrats–indeed the country–need a leader who will start laying the groundwork for Medicare for All now so it can become a reality in 2029 under a new president.

4. He has failed to champion a new generation of progressive leaders

At a time when voters are demanding bold new leadership, Chuck Schumer has repeatedly failed to embrace progressive candidates who are energizing the Democratic Party.

Perhaps the most glaring example is Zohran Mamdani. Even after Mamdani won the Democratic primary for New York City mayor and inspired an extraordinary grassroots movement, Schumer NEVER endorsed him. Even on Election Day, he refused to say whether he had voted for his own party’s nominee. What an astonishing failure by New York’s senior senator to support such an exciting new leader!

In Michigan, Schumer backed establishment favorite Haley Stevens over progressive Abdul El-Sayed, who defeated her in the Democratic Senate primary. Just two days before the general election, Stevens shocked Democrats by endorsing Republican Mike Rogers. Schumer condemned her betrayal, but the episode raised serious questions about his political judgment.

In Florida, progressive Angie Nixon proved to be a remarkable candidate, coming within three percentage points of defeating Republican Senator Ashley Moody in a state Trump had won by 13 points. Bernie Sanders held four rallies for Nixon, but the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee provided no financial assistance. Schumer failed to champion a candidate who, with stronger national support, might have delivered one of the election’s most stunning victories.

In Mississippi, Scott Colom mounted an extraordinary challenge to Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state that hasn’t elected a Democratic senator since 1982. Yet national party support came only late in the campaign, despite Colom’s unexpectedly strong showing.

These races raise a fundamental question: Why does Schumer repeatedly fail to recognize and invest in dynamic candidates who could transform the Democratic Party? Instead of nurturing emerging talent, he has too often backed establishment favorites or stood on the sidelines while grassroots movements lead the way..

5. He is a supporter of the military-industrial complex

While Americans struggle with soaring living costs, Washington continues pouring extraordinary sums into the Pentagon and the military contractors that profit from war.

For fiscal year 2027, Trump proposed an astonishing $1.5 trillion military budget. Schumer opposed the increase but has not made significant cuts to military spending a central Democratic priority.

Schumer has also been an unwavering defender of NATO and a leading advocate for military assistance to Ukraine. He has repeatedly attacked Trump for being “soft on Russia,” demanding tougher sanctions against Moscow and greater military support for Ukraine. He helped push through tens of billions of dollars in military aid and opposed interruptions in weapons shipments. Rather than making negotiations to end the war his central priority, Schumer has consistently emphasized military assistance, economic pressure, and strengthening NATO.

The next Democratic majority should challenge the enormous power of the military-industrial complex and redirect resources toward healthcare, housing, education, and other urgent needs. This is unlikely to happen with Chuck Schumer at the helm.

6. He won’t call for ICE to be dismantled

While Trump has escalated his immigration crackdown, Schumer has focused primarily on calls to reform ICE rather than abolish the agency. Senator Ed Markey has explicitly demanded that ICE be defunded and abolished, while Bernie Sanders has called for eliminating tens of billions in additional funding. Senator Andy Kim has repeatedly visited detention facilities, spoken directly with detainees, and fought to shut down Newark’s notorious Delaney Hall. Senator Chris Van Hollen even traveled to El Salvador to fight for the return of a wrongfully deported Maryland resident.

Schumer has spoken out against ICE abuses, opposed a new detention facility in New York, and helped advocate for the release of Bronx student Dylan Lopez Contreras. But as Senate Democratic leader, his approach has centered on reforming ICE rather than dismantling it.

That is simply not enough. With Stephen Miller, the architect of Trump’s mass deportation agenda and one of the most virulently anti-immigrant figures in American politics, now elevated to White House chief of staff, the danger to immigrant communities has only intensified. This is no time for timid reforms or half-measures. Democrats need Senate leadership willing to demand the abolition of ICE.

7. He voted for the disastrous Iraq War

In October 2002, Schumer voted to authorize President George W. Bush to invade Iraq.

In the lead-up to the Iraq War, millions of Americans took to the streets in protest, including hundreds of thousands in New York City on February 15, 2003, in one of the largest anti-war demonstrations in U.S. history. Despite this massive outpouring of opposition from his own constituents, Schumer had voted to authorize the disastrous war and went on to support billions of dollars in additional war funding.

The invasion, launched on the basis of lies about weapons of mass destruction, became one of America’s greatest foreign policy disasters. It killed enormous numbers of Iraqis, displaced millions, destabilized the region, and cost the United States trillions of dollars and thousands of American lives.

The historical record matters, especially as Congress again confronts questions of war, presidential power, and military intervention. His vote to authorize that disastrous war remains an essential part of evaluating his foreign policy judgment.

8. He opposed Obama's landmark Iran nuclear agreement

In 2015, Schumer broke with President Barack Obama to oppose the Iran nuclear agreement, widely regarded as Obama’s signature foreign policy achievement. The deal was a major diplomatic breakthrough, designed to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons without resorting to war. Yet Schumer sided with Republicans and hardline opponents of the agreement, provoking a fierce backlash from progressives and supporters of diplomacy.

His opposition raises an important question today: Does Schumer genuinely support a diplomatic resolution to the war with Iran, or is his opposition primarily driven by the fact that it is Trump’s war? His record of opposing one of the most significant diplomatic opportunities with Iran casts doubt on his commitment to pursuing diplomacy over military confrontation.

9. He has a history of giving in to Trump

In March 2025, Democrats faced one of their first major confrontations with Trump’s second administration. Republicans pushed through a government funding bill that Democrats had little role in writing, while Trump and Elon Musk were dismantling federal agencies and threatening essential public services.

Democrats had leverage in the Senate, where Republicans needed their votes to overcome a filibuster. But rather than insist on concessions, Schumer announced he would help advance the Republican bill.

The backlash was enormous. Progressive organizations called for his resignation, House Democrats erupted in anger, and even Nancy Pelosi publicly broke with Schumer.

Schumer argued that a government shutdown would give Trump and Musk even more freedom to dismantle the federal government. But his critics saw a fundamental failure of leadership: Democrats had an opportunity to confront the administration and instead helped pass its funding legislation.

The episode became a defining moment in Schumer’s leadership—and a source of lasting doubts about how aggressively he will confront Trump in future battles.

10. He has failed to challenge the corporate power driving inequality and environmental destruction

Schumer’s record reflects the limits of an establishment Democratic Party that too often compromises with powerful corporate interests.

In 2022, Schumer struck a deal with Senator Joe Manchin to fast-track energy projects, including fossil fuel infrastructure, provoking outrage from environmental justice groups. In 2024, he championed a bipartisan immigration bill that would have sharply restricted asylum protections.

And now, in November 2026, Schumer voted to advance legislation that environmental groups have dubbed the “dirty data center deal.” The bill would accelerate permitting for massive AI data centers, pipelines, and other energy infrastructure while weakening environmental protections. Tribal leaders warn that it would also undermine tribal sovereignty by weakening consultation requirements and making it harder for Indigenous communities to protect their ancestral lands, cultural heritage, and sacred sites. Despite protests by environmental and Indigenous rights groups, Schumer voted to move the legislation forward, arguing that the bill could lower energy costs.

Democrats face a fundamental choice between accommodating powerful industries and protecting communities, workers, and the environment.

Schumer’s incremental reforms in areas such as climate investments, prescription drugs, and infrastructure legislation are no substitute for confronting the enormous power of corporations and billionaires.

The voters have spoken. They want more than a change in which party controls Congress—they want a change in direction, a break from politics as usual, and leaders willing to challenge entrenched power.

Will Democrats in the Senate embrace the change voters demanded, or return to the same old leadership that has failed to deliver it?

Please go here for the original article: https://www.commondreams.org/opinion/should-chuck-schumer-be-senate-majority-leader

The Deeply Disturbing Track Record of Hakeem Jeffries

Jeffries and Schumer must go! We must stand against those who are in the pockets of AIPAC, who support neoliberalism, and who have a long track record of endorsing a toxic status quo. It is far past time to recognize the harm that those like Hakeem Jeffries has caused and work together to dismantle the neoliberal forces within the Democratic Party which have for decades been acting on behalf of their wealthy donors rather than We The People and the planet. WE VOTED FOR CHANGE! Please call your representatives and say NO to Jeffries and Schumer and that they must be blocked from leadership positions within Congress. — Molly

For education’s sake, a sampling on what Minority Leader for the U.S. House of Representatives, Hakeem Jeffries, has voted for:

H.Res. 719 - Honoring Charlie Kirk
H.R. 8034 - Arming Israel's genocide
H.R. 6090 - Making criticism of the State of Israel a hate crime
H.Res. 883 - Designating the phrase "from the river to the sea" as antisemitic.
H.Res. 888 - Made denying Israel's "right to exist" antisemitic H.Res. 798 - Condemned anti-genocide protests on campuses
H.Con.Res. 57 -- Declared Israel as “not racist” and “not apartheid”
H.R. 5323 - happily allocated $1 billion more Iron Dome (in 2021)
H.R. 7006- Cut funding for UNRWA and stated USA would not recognize the International Criminal Court
H.Res. 481-Called ‘anti-Zionism’ antisemitic
H.R. 6408-Removed tax-exempt status for groups opposing genocide
H.R. 6679-Restricted admission to the USA for PLO reps
H.Res. 927-Condemned college presidents over bogus allegations of campus antisemitism
H.Res. 11-Objecting to the UN resolution criticizing Israeli occupation in Palestine
H.Con.Res. 58 - Denounced the "horrors" of socialism
S. 1582- let Crypto do whatever it wants
H.R. 1346- Fuel "choice" bill that increased fossil fuel emissions by 25% through added ethanol
H.R. 5009 -Supported defense authorization that restricted gender-affirmation.
H.R. 6544- Weakened nuclear regulatory power
H.R. 5110-Allows the government to give money to school firearms training.
H.R. 3746-Gutted NEPA, approved controversial pipeline, tighter restrictions on SNAP

Historical Totals (1990–2024 / All Cycles): Across his career and broader pro-Israel industry classifications tracked by OpenSecrets Pro-Israel Recipients, Jeffries has accumulated roughly $1.74 million from sources in the pro-Israel donor category (which includes multiple PACs and associated individual givers, rather than AIPAC alone). Other trackers estimate direct and earmarked pro-Israel/AIPAC-related contributions across specific campaign cycles at varying thresholds.

He’s a sellout for whomever has a check in hand, genocide, discrimination, hate crimes be damned.

Copied from Gabriella Tebbens.

Friday, November 13, 2026

EXCELLENT! — Matthew Cooke: Does Israel Have a Right to Exist? Does Any Nation?

Deepest bow of respect and gratitude and love for Matthew Cooke and the sacred wisdom that flows through him. This is so excellent, so profound and wise! It is exactly these reflections of larger pictures and deeper wisdom which are illuminated here that empowers us to awaken from our illusions, our indoctrination, our ignorance. Hopefully these deep and sacred truths will continue to be recognized, absorbed, and shared far and wide. — Molly

Does Israel Have the Right to Exist?
Does Any Nation?

No, of course not. People have rights. The concept of a state's right to exist is not recognized in any international law. The question “Does Israel have a right to exist?” is a little rhetorical trick designed to make the rights of certain people disappear, and we have an obligation to dispense with any concepts that deny universal human rights.

This applies not only to every nation, but to the entire nation‑state concept, which does not have a right to exist. It is an ideology we call nationalism that is brand new, invented less than 250 years ago, and instantly turned into a tool for denying people their universal human rights.

Albert Einstein, a Jewish scientist who gave us our most precise understanding of the entire physical universe, called nationalism a disease, the measles of mankind.

Erich Fromm, the Jewish psychologist who helped define our understanding of universal basic human needs, called nationalism idolatry and insanity.

Hannah Arendt, the Jewish philosopher who survived the Nazi regime, explained that the expansion of European power into non‑European territory was not only the prelude to but the actual beginning of the totalitarian movements.

George Orwell, who wrote our textbook on the total loss of human rights, said: “Nationalism is not love of one’s country. It is the will to dominate others in its name.”

All of our greatest minds observed that at the moment organized religion and royalty ceased to work as a compelling story for the control of populations, a new religion was created that was even more effective for that purpose.

A good story has always been the most powerful weapon on earth. Using the revolutionary invention of the printing press, authorities could now mass‑produce a new story to capture humankind, and that was nationalism: an imaginary group identity based on a cartoonish version of history, glorifying conquerors as saints, turning political texts into holy scrolls, real estate into holy land, doubters into heretics, and replacing God with the state.

A state demands the standardization of language and the flattening of local cultures. It is an identity management system deployed to keep people kettled into zones and divided from each other, easily conquered and ruled by another aristocracy.

Like all new‑age religions, nationalism promises individual empowerment, cultural supremacy, safety, and protection from invasion and exploitation—and like every other cult, it delivers the exact opposite, which we can see because here we are at our third apex of nationalism in less than 100 years. Over 70 percent of our world now lives under oppressive regimes with record‑breaking inequality and a total collapse of any standards of ethics.

The followers of nationalism have reshaped their personalities to reflect their cult leaders and have lost everything of value: their connection to the outside world, their dignity, and any sense of reality. Cult propaganda teaches us that nationalism is as old as civilization. It is not. The word “nation” was born as an insult. It was first used by ancient Rome to describe foreigners as a monolith. If you were a nation, a natio, you were an outsider, removed from civilization, without any legal standing, without any civic identity. You were an undifferentiated mass, not really even a people, a horde.

The original concept of being a citizen did not refer to an amorphous nation, an undifferentiated mass thousands of miles wide. A citizen was, in reference to living in the city, a city dweller whose legal rights were guaranteed by a political structure—for example, a republic, a res publica, meaning a thing that is owned and operated by the public. In the year 2026, after 6,000 years of recorded history, with the whole record of human wisdom available to us, after having sifted through some really bad concepts and barbaric legal systems, we actually discover one principle. There is one legal right and obligation demanded by every wisdom tradition on every continent in every era since the dawn of time. The story of Jesus Christ calls it the greatest commandment of all: “Love thy neighbor as thyself.” And that includes the foreigner, and the recognition that there is no such thing.

Now we have three cults whose members include a small number of fanatics who have flipped our greatest commandment on its head in their rush toward Armageddon, and these three cults use the ideology of nationalism as their favorite tool for indoctrination. The first cult is Christian Zionists, who think that Jesus is going to return once the Jews are restored to the Holy Land, triggering Armageddon and sending the Christians—well, not all of them, just the chosen ones—into heaven and everyone else into a lake of fire. So they are starting World War III to put themselves in control of the timeline, since apparently they are so chosen they get to tell God what to do.

The second cult are Jewish Zionists, an even smaller group who believe that they are the chosen people and that God promised them the most holy lands on earth because they, and only they, are the true descendants of Abraham, which gives them the right to determine who is a chosen person and who should have their houses stolen, bombed, hunted, killed, tortured, or worse. Never mind that the story of Abraham is a cultural myth to which half of the whole world claims descendancy—a story about a wanderer, a refugee who treated all strangers as welcome guests and who was willing to surrender all his earthly claims and possessions, everything, to God.

Not a man with a beard in the sky—God as an icon made in the image of Roman emperors—but that which is beyond concepts, forms, and idols: a first cause, one unfathomable reality that must precede all beginnings and endings, that is closer to us than the innermost and furthest outside of all that can be seen and cannot be seen. Abraham most likely used a word for God that sounded like the Aramaic word that Jesus most likely used for God, which was “aloha,” which sounds like “Allah,” because these words all share one linguistic root, all branches of one tree, all of which honor Abraham.

The story of Abraham, when seen as a metaphor for the temporary nature of the material world, is a metaphor for all humankind, because at the end of each of our journeys in this form, like Abraham, all of us will be called to surrender everything. This is like the word “Israel,” a name given in an ancient story to the character of Jacob because he wrestled with God, a struggle between surrendering his ego or being consumed by it. The struggle crippled him, as it cripples us all. “Israel,” he who struggles with God, is also the story of all humankind.

Israel is mentioned not only in the Torah but in the Christian Bible and in the Muslim Quran. In the story of Genesis, which was used as justification for the creation of a modern European‑style ethno‑nation‑state, back there in Genesis when God tells Abraham “I will make of you a great nation,” the original word in that story, later translated into “nation,” means a people, a family. It has no territorial, legal, or political meaning whatsoever.

Although the current concept of Israel the nation‑state sells itself with the PR strategy that it exists to provide self‑determination to the descendants of Abraham, in its practical application it is the determination that the stranger is the enemy, which cannot be the religion of Abraham, because Abraham represents humanity, of which we are all descendants. That brings us to the third cult, the most powerful of all: the worship of the golden calf. Its followers believe that money and power are the highest measure of human worth and that those who have captured the most are the world’s true chosen people.

This is the religion of all the leaders of our Fortune 1000s, a list that does not measure the value provided to humankind. It is a list of those who have taken the most from us, those who are profiteering from the crimes of the first two cults, bringing us all to the brink of global economic collapse and World War III. If the greatest commandment of humankind is to love thy neighbor as thyself, there can be no greater sin than desecrating our most sacred stories as justification for dividing humankind between those who are deserving of human rights and those who should be sacrificed on the altar of their idols.

When we zoom out of their delusions, we find we are not actually living on a flat earth of linear thinking. We are in a round, connected world where we cannot separate ourselves from each other. Oil, gas, and pharmaceuticals all go through a narrow strait that we named Hormuz, as well as helium, which we use for MRI machines, fiber optics, and semiconductors. Those semiconductors come from people we group together and call “Taiwan.” Then there are millions of people who export memory chips, and because we cannot keep track of more than maybe 150 people, we call everybody there “South Korea.”

“India” is a blanket name we use to describe a huge piece of land where many people are making vaccines. There is this huge part of a continent that is home to something like a thousand cultures, but we call that whole thing “China,” because our minds and language limit us to communication possibly a few ticks above a chimpanzee, but we cannot really be sure. Anyway, there are millions of people there who make stuff that we all use and need. Because so much of that stuff now relies on batteries, we have to get cobalt, which has to be mined in a place with millions more people, but because we cannot remember more than 20 names at a time, we just call all of those people “Congo.”

Not far to the south is home to one of our world’s oldest civilizations, the Kingdom of Kush, the Nubian Empire. We call that whole place “Sudan.” Under the ground there is gold and something called chromite, which European and Gulf state nationalists steal, while the people who live on that land are also being sacrificed. This is just a list of the global economic chokepoints that are currently under siege, at war, or under imminent threat of war, which hold resources that the entire population of planet Earth depends on.

To wrap this up, the founder of game theory, John von Neumann, showed that the most likely inevitable endpoint of a world like ours, organized around sovereign nations competing for global resources, was war—eventually nuclear war and mutually assured destruction. That is why our greatest modern minds called nationalism insane, a disease, a death cult. It is why our atomic scientists just moved the doomsday clock to 89 seconds to midnight. With the technologies that humankind has invented and grown entirely dependent on, we can no longer survive without global cooperation.

Not cooperation between nations—a concept that refers to formless hordes living outside of civilization—but cooperation between our cities, neighborhoods, and communities, the places human beings actually live. The word “nation,” from natio, means a people born together. For this concept to actually reflect reality, we have to recognize that the earth is the home of humankind. This world is our nation, where we are born together.

Our individual identities are a patchwork of interconnected cultures whose family lines trace back hundreds of thousands of years. They intersect over and over again. All of us are related: one bloodline. All the land holy. All the people chosen. All of them our people, with a right to exist.

So Israel, like every conceptual political framework on earth—the US, Saudi Arabia, Iran, China, Russia—must guarantee equal rights to all religions, ethnicities, all the tribes of humankind. We can never allow those rights to be conditioned by imaginary lines in ever‑moving sands. As long as we do that, rights will be reduced to permits, revocable at any time for any reason by those claiming to be the chosen people, and atrocities are guaranteed.

To properly care for our children, we must reclaim the basic tools of civilization. Our water, land, and essential infrastructure are all res publica, owned by the public. To reclaim them means taking the advice of that US president when the world was defeating the Nazis the first time—Roosevelt—who advised that bringing an end to fascism, the extreme result of nationalism, requires breaking up all the big corporations that claim ownership over this place, taxing wealth hoarding, redirecting the energy of our labor back toward our well‑being, and guaranteeing universal economic rights worldwide.

This would cost a fraction of what we waste today on endless wars and extraction enterprises that provide nothing in return but Armageddon. So this is our starting point. All of our world’s most pressing issues—poverty, healthcare, the toxification of our air, water, and soil—can be resolved by reminding ourselves that the purpose of our economic and political systems is to care for all humankind and our children. Anything less means the end of humanity, the species and the quality that makes us human. That quality is the holy grail. It is the only holy war worth fighting—the one that protects its flame.


Matthew Cooke has written, directed, edited, & filmed seven documentaries. His work has earned an Oscar nomination, a "Best Writing Award" from the International Documentary Association, & multiple audience & festival awards. He founded the Survivors Guide to Earth newsletter and resource website: https://www.survivorsguidetoearth.com/members

Please go here for the original transcript: https://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/no-state-has-a-right-to-exist-only-people-do/

More videos by Matthew Cooke: https://www.youtube.com/@MatthewCookeOfficial

Matthew Cooke's website: https://www.matthewcooke.com/